Monday, September 04, 2006

Worst Song Ever?

The other day I heard the Aerosmith song Dude Looks Like a Lady and the thought crossed my mind, could this actually be the worst song ever? Let's see how it does on some important "Bad Song" criteria.

1)Badly Catchy
Obviously, you could make a much less listenable song than almost anything on the radio. Is cats screeching over discordant guitar chords harder to listen to than Dude Looks Like a Lady? Of course. But you would never put it on and it would never be on the radio, so you'd never be tortured by it. No, the worst song ever needs to not only by radio accessible, but the type that sticks in your head. It doesn't matter if you turn off the radio, b/c it will be back. I think Dude Looks Like a Lady definitely qualifies in this category, with its annoyingly repetitive anthem-like chorus.

2)Pointlessness
Would the world have changed in any way if Dude Looks Like a Lady had never been sung? Exactly. There is just no reason for its existence. Possibly, you could argue that it gets at the Crying Game subconsious fear in men. But then it should have been called "Lady Is a Dude" (and anyway, Pharcyde covered this territory well with Oh Shit).

3) Negative Connection
When you end up connecting a song to a bad story or negative experience, it can often make a bad song terrible. What makes Dude Looks Like a Lady even a worse song for me is my sister telling me that a fraternity across the street from her used to play "Sigma Beta Pheta" to the tune of "DLLAL". Not my experience, but certainly adds an extra cringe factor when I hear it.

So yes, after really analyzing it, I think I have convinced myself. Dude Looks Like a Lady just might be the worst song ever.

Labels:

15 Comments:

Blogger Michael5000 said...

Not that you asked, but "Dude Looks Like a Lady" is probably the most famous song that I, inexplicably, have never heard. I don't know where I was at the time -- in fact, I don't even know when that time was. I think it was several years later that I first heard the song mentioned, and my reaction was -- "no, that's not a real song, is it?" I've been told that it kind of depends how you look at it.

The two songs I have always been in awe of for their sheer, polished, beautifully-crafted and hyper-produced badness are REO Speedwagon's I Can't Fight This Feeling Anymore -- "it's time to bring this ship into the shore/throw away the oars/forever" -- and the Peter Cetera & Amy Grant duet The Next Time I Fall in Love -- "The next time I fall in love/I'll know better what to do/the next time I fall in love/ooh ooh ooh ooh ooh ooh/the next time I fall in love/the next time I fall in love/it will be with you."

I know this kind of dates me, but whatever.

11:29 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

GOD I HATE DUDE LOOKS LIKE A LADY AND I HATE YOU A LITTLE BIT FOR PUTTING IT IN MY HEAD. DAMN IT!!!

I don't think it's the worst EVER, but definitely in the .. top 10? top 5? Other darci nominees: 1. Sledgehammer? I may be an outsider on this one, but 30 seconds of this song kills me. 2. Shiny Happy People. Makes me feel better Michael Stipes has it too. and 3. that F*&#% b-52 song.. love shack. Might actually top my list. (Actally come to think of it, any B-52 song.)

I'm too tired to attack this question tonight, but I will ponder it. I think you've inspired a blog ;-)

11:59 pm  
Blogger chuckdaddy2000 said...

Amy Grant Duet? Terrifying. And Darci, I think I'm with you 3/3, including "Sledgehammer."

And Petrovich, thank you for placing DLLAL in its approriate place in the the heavy metal timeline. But I'm not sure about "Don't Worry Be Happy". Annoying, yes, but kind of creative. Like wasn't his band different parts of his body? That gives Mr. McFerrin at least some points.

8:27 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

--Sussudio by Phil Collins
--Who Let the Dogs Out by Baha Men (?)
--We Built this City by Starship or Jefferson Airplane
--Rico Suave

SUNGLASSES AT NIGHT

Anything by Huey Lewis and the News

It hurts.

8:32 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Looks like you are on your own with DLLAL. Didn't even rate on Blender's 50 Worst Song list...I called it on We Built this City.

My prize is that the song will be stuck in my head for eternity.

8:37 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Link to Blender's list: http://www.blender.com/guide/articles.aspx?id=786

8:38 am  
Blogger Michael5000 said...

Wow, hadn't thought about "We Built This City." Bad, bad, bad, bad, song -- EXCRUCIATING DJ interlude.

The Huey Lewis catalog is a good bulk nomination, too. Hearing Huey Lewis always puts me in a philosophical state of mind: what is it, exactly, that makes some music good -- and other music REALLY FUCKING AWFUL.

On the other hand, I don't know what y'all have against the goofy, loveable "Love Shack." Are you anti-puppy, too?

9:36 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

well, first of all, "we built this city," wwwaaayyy better than LoveShack. Jump in my chrysler it's as big as a whale and it's about to set sail? Not only is the song awful, but the group seems to be comprised of the ugliest, most awkward looking folk ever. I mean if your music is going to suck at least give me something nice to look at while you wail and blather.

Sussido IS an excellent nominee to the list. Huey, awww poor Huey. Maybe an innovator in his time, but today maybe not. Come on, you have to like the Back to the Future song a little?

12:16 pm  
Blogger Michael5000 said...

Yeah, Chrysler, big as a whale... it's, uh, redolent with youthful exhuberance!

Hell, the B-52s weren't exactly making art for the ages, but they were exploring their own lunatic fringe and I've always given them extra credit for that. They made Freddy Schneider, the one person in the band who couldn't sing a note, more or less the lead vocalist, and if a little thing like that is going to bug you than, yeah, you're not going to love "Love Shack." Oh, and the lyrics are kind of silly.

Huey Lewis and the News were the exact opposite, doing absolutely nothing even remotely surprising. If your insurance agent and his buddies got together and played that music in a bar every other Wednesday, you'd be happy that your insurance agent had a creative outlet. Hell, I'm happy that Huey Lewis and his buddies had a creative outlet. It's really the mentality behind the collective decisions that put their mid-tempo dreck on the airwaves that needs to be ruthlessly, ruthlessly purged from our culture.

Chuckdaddy, can you do something on basketball next? I'm trying to get some work done.

1:03 pm  
Blogger Michael5000 said...

BTW, that Blender list is a great read -- thanks for the link, emho.

1:05 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Huey! No meesing with my man Huey! And he is way more edgy than an insurance salesman. Remember the song "I Want A New Drug"? Besides PUSHING THE ENVELOPE it was a perfect summation of that light-hearted hedonistic time in the 80's.

3:20 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

HAHAH LOL. Comment of the year nomination: "Chuckdaddy, can you do something on basketball next? I'm trying to get some work done."

10:25 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Any band that sings a song called "Hip to Be Square" might as well enter a retirement home immediately.

8:27 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

i have been reading the xpress without adding any thoughts but i cannot keep silent. The worst song ever is "It's Hard for a Pimp." By 36 mafia. If anyone saw the oscar performance they will have to agree. john stewart couldn't even think of anything funny to say, he was struck dumb by the grating, tuneless tune.

7:25 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Cmon its not the worst. It may be their worst but not the worst song ever.

How about...
Me and You and a Dog Named Boo
Muskrat Love
I'm Too Sexy
Get Out of My Dreams, Get into My Car

Theres a lot of bad music out there. A lot of it from the 80s.

8:48 pm  

Post a Comment

<< Home